Skip to main content

The Talk


Talk delivered at Ignite-NM #14
September 11th, 2013


                A friend sent an e-mail about putting in a pitch for this event entitled, "Ignite-New Mexico."   After letting it sit in my in-box for a while, I thought, "What if I did a talk about talks?"  Seems to me that talks are a relatively recent thing, but the question I have is why.   Are we talking more?   For example, we have Ted Talks, Bioneers, BIL, South by Southwest, Poetry Slam, Story Slam, the Moth, and others.   We are talking more, but why?


                I asked a friend and he responded, "People need intellectual stimulation and they used to get it by reading.  Nobody reads anymore."
                Perhaps.  We certainly don't read Dostoyevsky or Joyce much anymore, but a lot of people who go to talks certainly read.   So I'm not so sure that intellectual stimulation could explain the talks popularity.
                Another friend suggested that people were missing collective experiences.  Growing up, I used to go to church every Sunday.   There I learned how not to fall asleep or fidget, but I also learned how listen to the preacher basically talk.  I haven't been to a church since high school.  I haven't really experienced that kind of talk, but the other function of church:  building community and hanging out, hasn't disappeared.   We see movies collectively, go to art openings and listen to rock shows so I'm not sure if a missing collective experience explains it either. 
                I think that if it's true that these talks are a relatively recent phenomenon, then you have to ask yourself why.   And my reasoning is a little bit complicated.  I think people are missing unmediated experiences.   If you watch the evening news, you know the anchor didn't create the whole thing.   And if you watch a movie, you know the producer didn't create the whole thing.   And even music, with auto-tuning and digital engineering, is often billed as a single person's creation, but it can't really be.   There's committees that write television shows, change the ending of movies based on audience feedback.   There are songs that are sold and then recorded by the people who bought them.  I listened to the president make an argument for bombing Syria and I couldn't help but think the whole thing was some sort of sinister plan to make us do it or make us not do it.  It was part of a bigger plan that felt orchestrated no matter which way you looked at it.
                I think we just want something that's real.  And talks because they quite often talk about things that noone would share with a complete stranger, talks because they leave the speaker vulnerable and exposed, and talks because they seem so out of left field and can't be anything but real do that.  

                Ultimately, though, I'm not sure if there is an answer.  Maybe we do need more intellectual stimulation or yearn for different collective experiences or really want people to be vulnerable and don't want to feel like it's all calculated?  I don't know.   I know that talks are popular.   But even this is mediated in a way.   So why are you here?
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

"That's Scaughtland for ya!"

The United Kingdom Up at the top of that map, basically the top half, is a tiny nation with a big footprint.  With roughly the same population as Minnesota, Scotland has a land mass the size of South Carolina, yet there are more people in the United States that have Scottish and/or Scotch-Irish ancestry than live in Scotland. My family is one of those. In the course of growing up, I was indoctrinated to celebrate my Scottish ancestry (primarily by my grandmother but we'll talk about that later).      So a year ago, my wife took a trip with her mother to Japan.  I looked at the pictures that she posted, and when I'd talk to her on the phone, I noticed something.  She was happy.  This is not to say she's always unhappy, but this was different.  She was having a good time, engaged in the world, curious, and happy-like no matter what the challenge.  And traveling to Japan with her mother posed some interesting challenge...
Post a Comment
Read more

Keith Jarrett: The Koln Concert and What it says about Creativity

Life is about listening.   Sometimes what life is saying comes at you in in strange ways.   On Friday, I was reading this story on Salon.com and it mentioned that few jazz musicians have the same clout as they once did.  Of the few who still draw considerable audiences, it mentioned Keith Jarrett .   I don't know Keith Jarrett, but I've been trying to school myself on jazz for the better part of a year now.   Since I'm relatively new to this jazz thing, I want to make sure I'm really listening to what people think of as "great."   With that in mind, I bought a book:   The Penguin Guide to Jazz Recordings .   Under Keith Jarrett they mention the album,  The Koln Concert as his best album (part of any enthusiasts' "Core Collection").   So, when I saw the album while perusing Mecca Records in ABQ, I knew I had to buy it.   Life was talking. The Koln Concert  (So, go ahead and ...
2 comments
Read more

The Day the War Began

Originally written shortly after the protest in 2003, an audio of this was broadcast on KUNM on the year anniversary of the war's inception. Hopefully, reasons for writing about this will become fewer and fewer. The Day the War Began.             Three deep and two dozen across, the Albuquerque police department blocked eastbound Central Avenue. They wore Army fatigues, gas masks and helmets, held black batons, yet had no badges or name tags that identified each as a person, an individual. Judging from the surrounding army of police cars and police horses, and the four cruisers that closed Central further to the east, their function was clear. Not only do the authorities want to silence dissent, but they want to keep those not politically vocal from becoming aware of dissent at all.             One of the cops held what looked like a toy water cannon and swung it back and fo...
Post a Comment
Read more